We are all wanderers on this earth. Our hearts are full of wonder, and our souls are deep with dreams.

Sunday, August 28, 2011

The Star's Hope
Classic Tarot by Carlo DellaRocca
Published by Lo Scarabeo 2000
The Star is always trotted out as one of the most wonderful cards, always.  Then why, when I see it, doesn't it make me happy?  I've said before it could be that I'm more geared toward immediate gratification so when I see the Star it tells me I'm on the right track but it's going to be a good while before I reach my goal and that just frustrates me.  It's always good to see the Star coming up for what a romantic partner thinks of you, but that too kind of irritates because inevitably the ones who always think the Star of you are the ones who also keep you at a distance.  Like you're up on some lofty pedestal or something.  Since readings have been sparse lately -- cue shameless promotional plug: it would be a great time to schedule a tarot reading with me now because there will be little to no wait -- I've had some time to poke around and research this card that seems oh so great but always bothers me.  I think I've uncovered something more than a naked lady playing with water.

The generic description of the card features "a goddess"...wait, which goddess?  And do they call her a goddess because she is both beautiful and naked or because she represents a particular goddess myth?  Choosing to go with the latter, I researched goddesses associated with either stars or water.  I found Inanna, Sumerian goddess of rebirth.  Hold up.  Rebirth?  Wouldn't that be better associated with Judgement?  Maybe, but there's a lot more.  Others have seen the similarities to Inanna and the tarot Star card, too, and what they are seeing is more than rebirth but alignment with a myth that is only a part, but an important part, of Inanna's legend.  Typically, images of Inanna show her either richly dressed or naked.  In the story, "Inanna's Descent to the Underworld," which is most useful for the Star imagery, she is stripped of her clothing.  Also, for a time during that journey, nature "dies" with Inanna and nothing would grow.  It was only when she returned to earth that things began blooming and growing again, hence her fertility goddess role and the watering of the earth.  Also, her symbol all over Mesopotamia is the 8-pointed star. 

Maybe I should tell the story. Essentially,  Inanna needed to visit her sister Ereshkigal who rules the Underworld. She heard her sister's baneful moaning and felt compelled to see her.  Any trek to the Underworld risks death, so she garbed herself accordingly: with her crown on her head, lapis lazuli around her neck, a golden bracelet, and a royal robe on her body and a breastplate.  She also took a lapis measuring rod and line.  When she was announced at the gate, her sister became more agitated and only allowed each of the gates to be opened a crack and Inanna had to remove her garments and ornaments in order to squeeze through each one.  She arrived at her destination naked and vulnerable.  The judges of the Underworld ruled against her and her sister killed her.  She became a rotting corpse and was hung from a hook on the wall.

Her companion outside the gates waited three days and then went seeking help from various Gods and finally Enki,God of Wisdom and Water who had originally blessed Inanna prior to her descent, came to his aid. He created two creatures and gave them the food and water of life to take to Inanna.  They snuck into the Underworld and found Ereshkigal in a very distressed state, moaning and crying.  Whatever agony she named, they would speak it back to her.  Finally she stopped and blessed the creatures and promised to give them whatever they asked.  They asked for Inanna's corpse, of course. As part of the deal of reviving her, though, she had to choose another person to go in her place.  She ended up choosing her husband because while she was gone, he had gone about his life as if nothing had happened.  Though she loved him very much it was clear he didn't love her the same.

Carl Jung, pioneer psychoanalyst who worked extensively with archetypes and myth in his practice and writings wrote some commentary on the Inanna's Descent myth.  I found this commentary to be so very enlightening with respect to the Star imagery.  The commentary focuses on the Inanna story as it illustrates a journey of deep depression.  His commentary, even more than the myth itself, speaks to why this card doesn't always feel so "happy" or "good."  It represents the afterwards, the time following a very rigorous examination of one's shadow self, a time of deep darkness and depression.   It's as if there is a pause between the Tower and the Star, a time spent in the Underworld groaning, moaning, and dying, a time of utter hopelessness.  We don't see this in tarot as it happens in the nether realms, but it is important to understand the cause of the hope the Star implies.  The article states: "The solution to depression lies not in great intellectual power, nor in great emotional power. It comes from Wisdom, which encompasses all of the psychological functions."  Ah! The missing virtue in tarot! Prudence!  The hope she has comes from Wisdom, and from knowing that whatever depths she has visited can be overcome with Wisdom.  She has also discarded her former garments for she has learned their value is little compared to the experience of facing her shadow self and integrating it into her being and becoming whole.

Being a veteran of my own treks to the Underworld, I know intimately the cost of depression. Upon my return, I was not happy-go-lucky but I did acquire hope.  In the depths, I could not see what there was to look towards.  In my ascent, I had hope that things would get better, I would get better.  The Star is that time, when you have integrated something rather dark, tragic, painful and costly into your being and, surviving that after having already survived the Tower experience that preceded it, your skin still raw and wet from rebirth, your psyche still wounded and painful to the touch, you spend some time tending to that which you could not when you were "away."  Inanna's earth would not grow, so she is watering it to revive its life.  The water would not flow, so she is pouring her tears into the stream.  It is a time of reclamation, without which we could not move on.   You may have to cut ties with people who, as you found out when you were gone, didn't really give a crap about you, like Inanna's husband.  You start the process of pruning the overgrowth.  This isn't an easy time, but it is a hopeful time.  It's a time when others may expect you to be back to "your old self."  How do you tell them your old self has died, never to return?  Besides, it will be a while before the process of reclamation is done, before you get where you're appointed to go. But it will never be as it was before.  You are changed. Your direction will likely change.  This is a card of work and healing and growth and yes, rebirth.

Now I understand why it unsettles me so.  I know this work. There is a reason stars only shine at night and why the Moon follows this one in tarot progression.  It's like that poem by Robert Frost, "Stopping By Woods on a Snowy Evening."
Whose woods these are I think I know.
His house is in the village, though;
He will not see me stopping here
To watch his woods fill up with snow.
My little horse must think it queer
To stop without a farmhouse near
Between the woods and frozen lake
The darkest evening of the year.
He gives his harness bells a shake
To ask if there's some mistake.
The only other sound's the sweep
Of easy wind and downy flake.
The woods are lovely, dark and deep,
But I have promises to keep,
And miles to go before I sleep,
And miles to go before I sleep.


  1. Anonymous8:52 PM

    You are truely an amazing writer. Thank you for helping me learn so much about the tarot and often helping me put life in perspective.

  2. I am so stuck at the Star right now. Thank you for this post and for the perfect timing of it. Keep writing!

  3. Danita Wesch3:09 AM

    Very well written and informative, enjoyed reading your work!

  4. I am a survivor of depression myself and have been told often that my card is the Star, so I sort of knew that this card is not only hope , but also what comes before hope-a process of changing and learning that is often painful. Lovely text, Ginny.

  5. I have been enjoying your blog for a while. Thank you for this particular post. The story of Inanna's descent has been very important to me, but I had not made the connection with The Star, a card that makes more sense to me now.
    Blessings, Laurel

  6. I have truly struggled with this card and am just beginning to make more sense of it now, especially its place in the progression of the Major Arcana. It seems so correct now that it comes after the Tower but before the Moon, and then, finally, the Sun. Miles to go before I sleep. Someone very dear to me has been on her "ascent" from depression and this card came up in a recent reading she did for herself in the immediate future position. Awwww. I now understand exactly where she is. This is truly a GOOD card, yes, but it's not an easy time.

  7. I'd not heard of this connection with Innana before for the Star card. Might not the two Tigris and Euphrates rivers be indicated by the pouring water also?

    Recently I went back and read Arthur Edward Waite's "Pictorial Key to the Tarot" and was interested to read many things there that did not match my preconceptions of the book. As I'm sure many here know, this was the book written to go along with the Tarot deck that pretty much started the modern era of illustrated Tarot decks, the Rider-Waite Tarot.

    Anyway, I read there that the Star card also may be indicative of "Gifts of the Spirit" as well as Truth, truth being symbolized by the nakedness of the figure. Once everything has been stripped away only truth remains. A star is also very clear and brilliant in its light, like truth. I personally don't use "Truth" with the same meaning that zealous Christians use that term.

    I was also surprised by the books somewhat veiled references to Christian thought and how there are seven gifts of the Holy Spirit and there are seven stars shown on the card behind the main one. The book doesn't refer to gifts of the holy spirit directly but it seemed possibly implied. The book is full of unanswered statements.

    Now I'm not trying to start a whole christian/pagan debate here just pointing out some of the possibly more tangible meanings for the card.

    For me personally the Star card is my decision point for when I purchase a new Tarot deck. If I don't like the Star card in the deck then I will usually not purchase the deck.

  8. Thank you, Ginny, from the bottom of my heart....!
    I have always resonated with The Star of Arthurian Tarot deck.... and it always gave me a feeling of waiting through many, many births for what is ultimately yours.... very sad, in a way. And then, recently, a couple breaking up in spite of being intensely in love, came across this card in answer to "Will we ever....?" It was heart-breaking to watch the joy on the man's face and the sadness on the woman's...
    Now I know why, and maybe now I feel that women have a different connect to this card than men...
    However, hope transforms one day to trust...
    Warm regards,

  9. Hi Zoe,

    Yes, I think, in general, men do have a different connect to this card than women. When I'm doing a relationship reading for a man and the Star appears for his beloved, it often means he sees her as his future.

  10. Good description of the star because with temperance it is one of the most difficult card to explain. We never really know what to say about this card, we know it is a good major arcana but after that it is always difficult to make accurate prediction with this card. We usually know that the star is a positive card but not exactly why...

  11. Hi Diana, it's true, isn't it? We do sometimes find ourselves at a loss to say exactly why certain "good" cards are good. There is another analogous myth that is associated with the Star having to do with her being the source of all life, but I focused on this one for this post. It is a rich card full of intense imagery if we look for it.

  12. Anonymous10:50 PM

    Thank you, Ginny, for this post. I drew the Star today and have been seeking as much information about it as I can get my hands on. I'm going through a rough time right now with my career, and I'm grateful for the Tarot (and for people like you!)who help bring clarity into my thinking.

  13. I'm glad it was helpful. The Star has always both encouraged and frustrated me. It tells us we are on the right track, but what we are aiming for is still a long ways off. This story helped me understand why.

  14. Anonymous3:46 PM

    Great post!! Do you know from which deck the second card comes (SVII Le Stelle)? It is lovely! Thank you so much! I love your blog!

  15. Croatian Mystery Trumps -- Majors only.


Please do not post links. Your comment will be deleted. Thank you.